Responsible AI for Self-directed Enquiry.

The questions we asked

  1. Warrant

    How can AI judgments become traceable to their underlying reasons, evidence, and uncertainties?

  2. Legitimacy

    How can AI systems support critical reflection and human agency rather than replace independent judgment?

  3. Legality

    How can applicable legal requirements and compliance assessments become transparent and technically verifiable?

  4. Practical context

    Does AI-assisted reflection strengthen people’s capacity for independent judgment, or create new forms of dependence on AI itself?

Traceable judgments, critical reflection and responsible AI governance

Responsible AI is often defined through principles and commitments. But how can we examine the reasoning behind AI assessments, challenge their conclusions, and ensure that human judgment remains central?

rAISE (Responsible AI for Self-directed Enquiry) explores how AI systems can support critical reflection and accountable decision-making without replacing human judgment. Building on aihorizon R&D’s Responsible AI Framework, the project develops approaches that make normative commitments, supporting evidence, underlying assumptions, and the limits of AI assessments transparent and contestable.

At its core is a distinction between four dimensions of responsible AI: epistemic justification, normative legitimacy, legal compliance, and contextual appropriateness. Rather than collapsing these dimensions into a single assessment, rAISE seeks to make their different conclusions, potential conflicts, and underlying reasons visible, allowing people to examine and weigh them independently.

The project develops an interactive Reflection App in which individuals can critically revisit their use of generative AI, examine the reasoning behind assessments, and challenge underlying assumptions and normative standards. Specialised AI agents support this process through structured, traceable assessments while leaving the weighing of potentially conflicting considerations to human users.

A central research question is whether AI-assisted reflection strengthens people’s capacity for independent judgment or creates new forms of dependence on AI itself. By investigating how people engage with, challenge, and respond to AI-generated assessments, rAISE explores the conditions under which AI can support self-directed enquiry, responsible delegation, and accountable human–AI interaction.

Project status

In development

Reflection app, normative scaffold and agent repository planned